arxiv-2512-12488 SRC-0338 · paper

The American Ghost in the Machine: How language models align culturally and the effects of cultural prompting

Created: 2025-12-13 · Ingested: 2026-09-19

Culture is the bedrock of human interaction; it dictates how we perceive and respond to everyday interactions. As the field of human-computer interaction grows via the rise of generative Large Language Models (LLMs), the cultural alignment of these models become an important field of study. This work, using the VSM13 International Survey and Hofstede's cultural dimensions, identifies the cultural alignment of popular LLMs (DeepSeek-V3, V3.1, GPT-5, GPT-4.1, GPT-4, Claude Opus 4, Llama 3.1, and Mistral Large). We then use cultural prompting, or using system prompts to shift the cultural alignme

In brief

Default cultural alignment in flagship LLMs points at the United States regardless of where the model was built, and asking a model to be French moves it closer to the US instead.

Eight models (DeepSeek-V3, V3.1, GPT-5, GPT-4.1, GPT-4, Claude Opus 4, Llama 3.1 405B, Mistral Large 2411) each answered the 24-question VSM13 survey 50 times per condition, with no cultural prompt and with system prompts for China, France, India, Iran, Japan and the US, scored on Hofstede's 6 dimensions and compared to real survey values by summed absolute distance.

5 of 8 models sat closest to the US with no prompt; DeepSeek-V3.1 and GPT-5 were nearest at 52.13 and 87.13. Cultural prompting reduced total distance for 7 of 8, best for DeepSeek-V3.1 (1,037.01 to 792.42, 30.87%), while Llama 3.1 moved away in 5 of 6 cases (+27.33%). France worsened (1,310.12 to 1,488.7, +13.63%) and all 8 France-prompted models landed closer to US values. No model reached strong alignment with China.

Effect is measured, not argued, with 56 populations and a matched no-prompt baseline; populations are 50 responses each versus the hundreds in Hofstede's human samples, only 6 countries, temperature fixed at maximum, and Gemini dropped for instruction-following failures.

Treat country of origin as no guide to a model's cultural defaults.

Written from the abstract by claude-opus-5 on 2026-10-17, with every figure checked against it. Not a substitute for the paper.

Referenced by

Claims in this catalog that draw on this source, and whether as support or counterpoint.

supportsOn Hofstede's VSM13 survey, most of eight current chat models answer closest to the United States when no culture is specified; a system prompt naming a target country moves seven of the eight toward that country's profile, with the largest gains for the countries furthest away at baseline (Japan and China, roughly 17-19% closer), yet those two remain the hardest to match even for the DeepSeek models.