arxiv-2608-20975 SRC-0428 · paper

Belief Without Behavior: Measuring the Translation of Theory of Mind into Coordinated Social Action in Vision-Language Models

Tonglin Yan, Grégoire Sergeant-Perthuis, David Rudrauf

Created: 2026-08-21 · Ingested: 2026-10-17

https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.20975

Effective social interaction requires agents to translate mental state inferences into coordinated behavioral signals across verbal and nonverbal channels simultaneously. Yet existing benchmarks evaluate theory of mind (ToM) reasoning and embodied behavior in isolation, leaving unmeasured the gap between social inference and social action. We introduce MOSAIC (Multimodal Orchestration of Social Action, Inference, and Communication), a controlled benchmark in which two embodied agents interact across cooperative and competitive scenarios requiring integration of verbal statements, spatial traje

Referenced by

Claims in this catalog that draw on this source, and whether as support or counterpoint.

supportsIn two-agent embodied social tasks requiring coordinated gaze, movement and expression, fine-tuning open VLMs (8B-14B InternVL) by timestep-level action imitation on demonstrations from an architecture with an explicit belief module shifts trial outcome scores up or down depending on condition but does not make the student's nonverbal signals more directionally coherent, because cross-channel communicative coordination is a trial-level property that per-timestep supervision does not encode.
supportsIn two-agent embodied social tasks where one agent must guide or mislead another through movement, gaze and facial expression, open-source VLMs up to 15B show no reliable behavioral change when an explicit theory-of-mind order constraint is imposed, failing at two separate points: most do not produce directionally coherent nonverbal signals, and those that do (e.g. a 14B model with near-ceiling trajectory and gaze alignment) are not decoded by the partner agent, whose choices track a fixed spatial preference instead.