arxiv-2609-24369 SRC-0528 · paper

DeceptionAnalyser: A Web-Based AI Tool for Performing Structured Deception Analysis with Argumentation Schemes and LLMs

Created: 2026-09-21 · Ingested: 2026-10-17

Deception plays a central role in Intelligence operations, yet it remains difficult to analyse systematically without expert knowledge of reasoning patterns and cognitive manipulation. In computational argumentation, for instance, no scheme-level ground-truth corpora currently exist to support statistical validation. In this paper, we address this by introducing a set of ten argument schemes designed to model distinct forms of deception, each accompanied by structured premises and critical questions. In doing so, we introduce the first dedicated library of argumentation schemes specifically de

Referenced by

Claims in this catalog that draw on this source, and whether as support or counterpoint.

supportsWhen deception in narrative text is analysed by instantiating fixed argumentation schemes with an LLM (premise extraction, then critical-question evaluation), the scheme assessments are stable across ten different LLM backbones and repeated runs for clear-cut deception cases but grow inconsistent on ambiguous intelligence-style narratives.